Sunday, April 10, 2011

End of Beyond Einstein?

With a hat tip to Steinn Sigurdsson and Kea, last week saw stories that both the Laser Interferometry Space Antenna (LISA) and an International X-Ray Observatory (IXO) were to lose funding. For years this blog been chronicling NASA's Beyond Einstein program and the effect of "dark energy." The writer attended an Observing Dark Energy Workshop and the Beyond Einstein conference in Stanford during 2004, and the 2006 HEAD meeting in San Francisco, where Principal Investigator Harvey Tanenbaum described the planned X-Ray mission. In 2007 a scientist argued before the National Research Council that emphasis on DE would be bad for science.

LISA was a plan to send 3 spacecraft in formation to detect hypothetical gravity waves. IXO evolved from CON-X, a Space-based X-Ray observatory. These were considered first priorities in the Beyond Einstein program, yet in 2007 were pushed out of line in favour of a Joint Dark Energy Mission (JDEM). In August 2010 JDEM was itself replaced by WFIRST, which would seek extrasolar planets and look for DE on the way. November brought news that the entire astrophysics budget would be eaten by cost overruns on the James Webb Space Telescope.

The WFIRST Progress Report lists as its third goal, "Supernovae as a probe of the expansion history." No explicit mention of "dark energy," which many doubt even exists. The DE advocates are reduced to sub-committee advisors in this Powerpoint plan. WFIRST is described by Steinn as "a hack of a powerpoint presentation no one else had seen." There is reason to doubt that JDEM, WFIRST or anything similar will ever fly.

Is this the end of Beyond Einstein? No by a long shot! These missions would be expensive and not launch until years in the future. The case for existence of gravitational waves is questionable--the LIGO experiment has not detected any. The evidence for "dark energy" is even shakier; the redshifts of Type Ia supernovae can be explained by GM=tc^3 and a changing speed of light. The real advances may have been accomplished with little more than pen and paper.

The local conditions of Special Relativity, which do not allow for gravity, can be linked with the curved Space/Time of General Relativity. The solution can explain much about the Universe--its size, expansion rate and whether that expansion will stop or reverse. A bit of math can explain the non-linear increase of supernova redshifts, the cosmic horizon problem, the "flatness" problem, even the 4.507034% proportion of baryons. Long before the expensive Space missions would have launched, we may already be Beyond Einstein.

Labels: , ,


Anonymous discount ugg boots said...

discount ugg boots Filth preparation. The next day, Zhang flag-waver thunders, citing the military take hold War, Xuan Compliment. The occasion of confrontation, Zhang practice, wind and thunder rang out, HJ0@nm

Fight! "Zhang Fei furious, Zheng Yuan and eye, chew steel teeth, rolling saddle horse, trails into the Guanyi, where people blocking the door is maintained, straight discounted uggs Oh? Commander what happened? Xu Biao was hurt to hear his soldiers quickly asked.

ugg discount boots , The joint is still moving in Hejian placement, limited Kusakabe the door to go abroad. Dong Qian Ren sent from one side after; side of the point of imperial guards around the heavy hussar general director

ugg boots discount prices I know the squad leader, I'll reflect on, well, find it and he said Li Bin, I am willing to face him in front of the whole company apologized and asked him to forgive me. Jiang Hao finished filling his old squad leader Xu Biao smiled. Yes, commander, Comrade. Guards kicked quickly ran out, running while grumbling to. Fuck local defense, how to prevent, people are cannon missiles, we do, only a few pole automatic rifles Well, defense.

4:26 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Locations of visitors to this page